Crypto Bros Purchase Jodorowsky's Dune "Bible" for Thousands and thousands – The Mary Sue

Image from "Alejandro Jodorowsky's 'Dune.'" (Image: City Film and Snowfort Pictures.)
Final weekend, a crypto collective referred to as $SPICE DAO (Decentralized Autonomous Group) went viral on-line for sharing that not solely did they win a lately auctioned, uncommon copy of Alejandro Jodorowsky’s Dune manuscript for hundreds of thousands final month, however they’d embark on a mission to make the ebook public and accessible through an animated sequence.
We received the public sale for €2.66M. Now our mission is to:
1. Make the ebook public (to the extent permitted by regulation)
2. Produce an unique animated restricted sequence impressed by the ebook and promote it to a streaming service
3. Help spinoff tasks from the group pic.twitter.com/g4QnF6YZBp
— Spice DAO (🏜,🏜) (@TheSpiceDAO) January 15, 2022

Although I questioned why they’d publicly announce they have been doubtless going to commit a copyright crime, that they had us and lots of others on the first level (earlier than dropping us later). Once we final wrote in regards to the ebook’s public sale again in early November 2021, I stated, “Please, please, in case you are studying this, add a PDF of this ebook on-line or donate it to an establishment that may navigate opening it to the general public. Contemplate it a present to science fiction nerds, movie historians, archivists, and artists. I’m undecided if what I’m asking for is even authorized, but it surely undoubtedly feels like a tax write-off.”
Nevertheless, it was the weather that adopted that rubbed individuals the mistaken means. The information was met with backlash from many and even impressed its personal meme.
We received the public sale for €2.66M. Now our mission is to:
1. Make the film public (to the extent permitted by regulation)
2. Produce an unique animated restricted sequence impressed by the ebook and promote it to a streaming service
3. Help spinoff tasks from the group pic.twitter.com/OsQDMaCMyB
— kenzie (@pk_kenzie) January 17, 2022

We received the public sale for €2.66M. Now our mission is to:
1. Make the ebook public (to the extent permitted by regulation)
2. Produce an unique animated restricted sequence impressed by the ebook and promote it to a streaming service
3. Help spinoff tasks from the group pic.twitter.com/ecVNbaEw9r
— the thicc husband & father (@lukeisamazing) January 17, 2022

We received the public sale for $4.24. Now our mission is to:
1. Make the sport public (to the extent permitted by regulation)
2. Produce an unique animated restricted sequence impressed by the cardboard and promote it to a streaming service
3. Help spinoff tasks from the group https://t.co/5bi4zDBmOX pic.twitter.com/4ggrYBqJRd
— April King (@CubeApril) January 17, 2022

Quickly after the coveted ebook went up for public sale, $SPICE DAO swiftly took motion to accumulate the ebook. The group crowdsourced the funds to win the public sale, however within the meantime, one of many (then) leaders of this group, Soban Saquib, a.ok.a “Soby,” fronted $3 million wanted to win the Christie’s public sale. Technically, he received in December after which transferred the possession of the bodily ebook to the group, which took in round $12 million to reimburse Soby, pay for the supposed animated sequence, and extra. Just a few members could have entry to the bodily ebook for security causes.
It wasn’t till the January tweets and public declaration that some started to appreciate the problems with any steps ahead that the undertaking would take. As simple as it’s to giggle it off because the audacity of the crypto bro—ignoring legality and solely seeing inexperienced by believing that as a result of they personal a replica of a narrative/manuscript, they will do no matter with it—the reality of what’s occurring is far more difficult.
Many (doubtless most) individuals concerned with $SPICE DAO embody the brand new web archetype of the crypto bro and the “new cash” libertarian visionary. They understand at each flip the necessity to pivot (higher than doubling down, no less than, which could be very en vogue proper now) earlier than the studios and courts come for his or her necks. Nevertheless, the state of affairs is difficult by the acknowledged values of the group and competing visions.
Across the Discord (which at the moment comprises about 3,000 members), there could also be totally different concepts of what subsequent steps to take. Nonetheless, their web site (Dune.basis) outlines the targets of working in direction of preservation, accessibility, and consciousness.
$SPICE DAO stresses at each flip that they wish to know what the individuals need, they usually clearly define a voting system to make it semi-democratic. The catch is that that is all behind paywalls, and there’s nothing on the positioning that reveals this may change. Individuals who contributed to the crowdfunding that purchased the ebook really feel like their votes ought to matter extra as a result of they’ve extra to lose, “for the individuals” be damned. Nevertheless, if that is about sharing one thing for everybody, shouldn’t this be thought of a donation for the better good?
Studying by the boards (solely three threads in the mean time and one how-to thread) and Discord, there appear to be three motivations for individuals concerned: the idea within the acknowledged targets, the need to revenue, and the observer with a bucket of popcorn. Certain, there’s the occasional troll, however the teams encompass primarily the primary two.
Generally, it’s form of laborious to inform the place the leaders stand as a result of they speak about a democratic and clear course of, however a lot of that is shrouded in thriller and takes shopping for into the undertaking through $SPICE token (bitcoin) to have a say/vote. When publications like The Verge come out with articles asking respectable questions on $SPICE DAO’s targets and the way they plan to attain them, the official Twitter is hostile. Then, they share the article on Medium and Discord as essential and insightful.
On the boards (just like the Discord, however extra on matter), the opinions mirror the combined motivations of the group—which exist in any group. Nonetheless, individuals are additionally publicly selling concepts that go towards $SPICE DAO’s acknowledged values and targets. Multiple individual advocated for burning the already uncommon ebook to extend the worth of the digital belongings. When there was pushback, one commenter stated they don’t care what “normies that most likely didn’t even know the ebook existed assume.”
Below reported side of the hilarious Dune NFT factor is there’s additionally dialogue about whether or not to burn the ebook to boost the worth of the NFTs https://t.co/PT6Hf2OIK1 pic.twitter.com/FVYuF5eHlw
— Display Slate (@ScreenSlate) January 17, 2022

A extra current thread that’s lifeless silent proposed the concept of donating the “ebook to a good library or assortment which is able to make it legally accessible to the general public” and shutting down $SPICE DAO as a result of the undertaking was spiraling uncontrolled and away from the unique imaginative and prescient.
This proper right here is why it took everybody so lengthy to grasp what was occurring as a result of, individuals clearly seeking to make cash apart, there was a rising disconnect between people who purchased in to do one thing for the general public good and people saying, “We are able to do that, make cash, and legitimize this goldrush enterprise of Web3, crypto, and NFTs.”
One more reason there’s a misalignment between the competing values and supposed love “the imaginative and prescient Jodorowsky set forth” is as a result of there are only a few (if any) artists related to the unique undertaking working with $SPICE DAO. A studio could have stated Jodorowsky’s tackle the difference is over (there’s a complete glorious documentary about this), however this group isn’t working with many (if any) of the creatives whose work they worth a lot.
Whereas Frank Herbert could have handed, this undertaking goes past the writer as a result of this isn’t a couple of uncommon ebook copy. As an alternative, it’s with a uncommon copy of the manuscript of an adaptation, that includes work by many alternative creators. Judging by the group’s web site, it virtually appears that Jodorowsky and others have handed away, when they’re very a lot nonetheless alive and dealing on their craft.
(Sony Photos Classics)
Between Discord and on-line interactions, there isn’t any indication that anybody concerned with Jodorowsky’s Dune is working with $SPICE DAO’s undertaking. Whereas there’s restricted title dropping, they’re utilizing high-profile properties and associations to hype up fellow “spirit warriors.” These are individuals related to tasks like Kill Invoice and Love, Loss of life & Robots, and representatives like an “leisure legal professional” for Drake and varied unnamed animation studios.
Being a spinoff of a factor that’s itself a free model of one other factor isn’t inherently mistaken. Jodorowsky and Mobieus’s The Incal was the successor of his imaginative and prescient for Dune. The cash raised on this case might have skipped shopping for the ebook altogether to only make this undertaking primarily based on the pages of the manuscript floating round on-line (just a few clicks away from “Jodorowsky’s dune manuscript pdf” on Google) or by speaking to the creatives concerned.
They may have even used Web3 and NFTs for this undertaking and stated it was impressed by Jodorowsky’s Dune with out shopping for the ebook. It wouldn’t be as accessible for everybody (i.e., “normies”) and would stil entice some derision, however no less than the undertaking can be simple with its premise, aligned with its acknowledged targets, and contain restricted exploitation (as a lot as you’ll be able to contemplating how blockchains have confirmed to be damaging to the secondhand PC components economic system and the atmosphere). It will primarily be a fan undertaking, and hey, even Kickstarter is driving that blockchain prepare, so they’d have a house.
In the end, I believe the explanation this didn’t find yourself occurring is that too many individuals got here to make cash. That wasn’t the unique aim (confirmed by the truth that the aim is consistently altering because of the “democratic” construction), however those that got here in genuinely altruistic appear to have both left or ended up seduced by the spice.
(Picture: Metropolis Movie and Snowfort Photos)
Need extra tales like this? Grow to be a subscriber and assist the positioning!
The Mary Sue has a strict remark coverage that forbids, however isn’t restricted to, private insults towards anybody, hate speech, and trolling.—
Have a tip we must always know? [email protected]
(she/her) Award-winning digital artist and blogger with an curiosity in artwork, politics, id, and historical past—particularly after they all come collectively. This Texan balances book-buying blurs with liberal Libby use.
Have a tip or story concept? Electronic mail us. Or to maintain it nameless, click on right here.

supply